Nearly all batesvilleonline.com members were transferred to the new site, so you shouldn't need to create a new account. However, it wasn't possible to transfer user passwords, so you'll need to create a new one by going to batesvilleonline.com/login
and click the "Lost your password?" link. Then enter the email address you used with your previous batesvilleonline.com account and click the "Reset Password" button. You'll receive an email with information about completing the process, so be sure to check your spam folder.